Selling a Rental With a Flat-Fee or Discount Agent in Richmond: What Landlords Should Know

Short answer: a flat-fee or discount agent can work for selling a rental in Richmond, but only if you’re ready to do the jobs the agent won’t: scheduling showings around a tenant, handling repair requests, and keeping the deal together. In Virginia, an agent who offers reduced services has to list, in writing, which standard duties they won’t perform (Va. Code § 54.1-2138.1). That list is the first thing a landlord should read.

I talk with a lot of landlords who are tired of the rental and want to keep as much of the sale price as they can. A cheaper listing sounds like the obvious answer. Sometimes it is. Here’s how I’d decide.

What “flat-fee” and “discount” usually mean

The names get used loosely, so look at what you’re actually buying:

  • Flat-fee MLS listing: you pay a set fee to get the house on the MLS. You handle most of the rest.
  • Discount or reduced-commission agent: a lower fee, sometimes with a full set of services, sometimes not.
  • Limited service agent: Virginia’s legal term for an agent who provides only some of the standard duties. The written agreement must say so conspicuously and list the duties left out.

Every brokerage agreement in Virginia must be in writing, state the fee and how it’s paid, describe the services, and have a definite end date. If no end date is written in, it ends 90 days after signing (Va. Code § 54.1-2137). I’m not quoting any commission percentages here, because fees vary by company and are always negotiable.

Why a rental is harder than a regular listing

A flat-fee setup works best on an empty, clean house that shows itself. Most rentals aren’t that house.

Showings with a tenant

Under Va. Code § 55.1-1229, a tenant can’t unreasonably refuse to let the landlord show the unit to buyers, and the landlord must give notice and enter at reasonable times. Someone still has to make that happen. With a limited-service agent, that someone is usually you.

Repair requests after inspection

Rentals often come with deferred maintenance. When the buyer’s inspector writes up the roof, the water heater, or the electrical panel, someone has to negotiate. If your agreement doesn’t include negotiation help, you’ll be doing it yourself.

You’re managing from a distance

Many landlords don’t live near the rental. Lockboxes, contractor visits, and last-minute questions are harder to cover when you’re an hour or a state away.

Questions to ask before you sign

Ask Why it matters for a rental
Who schedules and attends showings? Tenant notice and access have to be handled every time.
Who negotiates offers and repair requests? Inspection lists on rentals are often long.
Which standard duties are excluded? Virginia requires that list in writing for limited service.
When does the agreement end? It must have a definite date, or it ends after 90 days.
Are there fees if it doesn’t sell? Some flat fees are paid up front, sale or not.

Costs that stay with you either way

A lower listing fee doesn’t remove the other costs of selling. Virginia charges a grantor tax on the seller (Va. Code § 58.1-802), you still pay off the mortgage and any liens, and the house keeps costing you money while it’s listed. If you sell a rental at a gain, depreciation recapture and capital gains rules may apply, so talk with a tax professional. IRS Publication 544 covers sales of business and rental property.

A third option: skip the listing

If the reason you’re looking at a cheap listing is that you want out without spending much, a direct sale may fit better. I buy rentals as-is, with or without tenants:

  • A written cash offer within 24 hours of seeing the house.
  • Calls returned within 3 hours.
  • No commission, and I pay the closing costs.
  • No repairs, no showings, and you choose the closing date. A local real estate attorney handles the closing.

My price on a house that needs work will usually be lower than a top retail price. If a listing would clearly put more in your pocket, I’ll say so.

FAQ

Is a flat-fee listing a good idea for a house with tenants?

It can be, if you’re willing to coordinate showings and negotiate repairs yourself. Virginia requires tenants not to unreasonably refuse showings, but landlords must give notice (Va. Code § 55.1-1229). Read which duties the agent excludes before you sign.

What does a limited service agent have to tell me in Virginia?

Under Va. Code § 54.1-2138.1, the written agreement must say the agent is acting as a limited service agent, list the specific services provided, and list the standard duties the agent won’t provide. The disclosure must be conspicuous.

Can I cancel a flat-fee listing agreement?

Check the agreement. Virginia brokerage agreements must have a definite termination date, and if none is stated, they end 90 days after signing (Va. Code § 54.1-2137). Ask a Virginia real estate attorney about early termination terms.

Do I still pay closing costs if I use a discount agent?

Usually yes. A lower fee doesn’t remove seller costs like the Virginia grantor tax, your mortgage payoff, or any liens. When you sell directly to me, I pay the closing costs.

Will you buy my rental if the tenant is still there?

Yes. I buy rentals with tenants in place or vacant, as-is. I’ll make a written cash offer within 24 hours.

This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. Talk with a Virginia real estate attorney or a tax professional about your situation.

Ready to see your numbers? Request your cash offer or Call (804) 293-0208. You can also compare a direct sale with listing, read how we buy houses, or see how long it takes to sell a rental.

Get More Info On Options To Sell Your Home...

Selling a property in today's market can be confusing. Connect with us or submit your info below and we'll help guide you through your options.

What Do You Have To Lose? Get Started Now...

We buy houses in ANY CONDITION in Virginia. There are no commissions or fees and no obligation whatsoever. Start below by giving us a bit of information about your property or call (804) 293-0208...

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Call Us!
(804) 293-0208