Short answer: Usually, yes. Under Virginia’s Fair Housing Law, a landlord must grant a reasonable request to keep an assistance animal, including an emotional support animal, when the tenant has a disability and a disability-related need for it. You may ask for reliable documentation if that isn’t obvious, but you can’t charge a pet fee, pet deposit or pet rent.
Your lease says no pets. Then a tenant says they have an emotional support animal, or hands you a letter they got online. It’s easy to be unsure what comes next: say yes, say no, or ask for proof. Virginia’s rules are more specific than most owners expect, so here’s what the law says, how to look at a letter, and the mistakes to avoid.
This article is general information about Virginia and federal fair housing rules, not legal advice. Every rental and every accommodation request is different. Talk to a Virginia attorney who handles landlord-tenant or fair housing law before you accept, deny or question an assistance-animal request. Law current as of November 20, 2026.
What Virginia law says
In Virginia, an emotional support animal can be an “assistance animal,” and an assistance animal is not a pet.
The state’s definition covers an animal that works or performs tasks for a person with a disability, or “provides emotional support that alleviates one or more identified symptoms or effects” of that disability. It doesn’t have to be trained or certified, and it doesn’t have to be a dog (Va. Code § 36-96.1:1).
A request that’s needed to give a tenant with a disability an equal chance to use and enjoy the home “shall be granted,” unless it would cause an undue financial and administrative burden or fundamentally change how you operate. Each request is decided case by case. You can deny one only if the person isn’t disabled, there’s no disability-related need, it’s an undue burden, or it’s a fundamental alteration. For animals, you can also consider whether this animal poses a clear and present threat of substantial harm that another accommodation can’t fix (Va. Code § 36-96.3:2).
What changed at HUD, and what didn’t
HUD withdrew its 2020 assistance-animal notice (FHEO-2020-01) and its 2013 notice, effective September 17, 2025 (Federal Register, 91 FR 17291). A May 22, 2026 memo to HUD staff says HUD will find reasonable cause only where the animal was individually trained, and that untrained ESA requests aren’t presumptively reasonable. The memo also says it doesn’t affect anyone’s right to sue in court (copy hosted by DREDF). None of that changes Virginia’s statute, which still names emotional support. Don’t tell a tenant “HUD says ESAs don’t count” without talking to an attorney first.
Are you exempt? Check carefully
A few small owners are exempt, but the conditions are narrow.
Virginia’s Fair Housing Law doesn’t apply to a single-family house rented by a private owner of no more than three single-family houses, but only if you rent it without any broker, agent, rental service or anyone in the business of renting homes, and without a discriminatory ad. It doesn’t cover Real Estate Board licensees. A building of up to four units where the owner lives in one is also exempt (Va. Code § 36-96.2). Federal law has a similar exemption (42 U.S.C. § 3603(b)).
The “four rental units” rule you may have heard about lets small owners limit rentals based on a tenant’s source of funds. It isn’t an ESA exemption. If a property manager handles your rental, you likely don’t qualify. Ask your attorney before you rely on any exemption.
How to check an ESA letter
You can ask for reliable proof when the disability or need isn’t obvious. You can’t demand a diagnosis, a registry or a certificate.
- Treat it as an accommodation request, however it reaches you. Write down the date and what was said.
- If the disability and the need are already obvious or known, stop there. The law says you may not ask for more verification (Va. Code § 36-96.3:1, subsection B).
- If not, ask in writing for reliable documentation of the disability and the need for the animal. It can come from anyone with a “therapeutic relationship” with the tenant: a mental health provider or licensed professional, but also a free peer-support group, a caregiver or another reliable third party who actually knows about the disability (subsections C and E).
- Read what you get. You have to evaluate it (subsection D). Does the writer know the tenant? Does the letter connect the need to the animal?
- If the source seems questionable, focus on the source, not the condition. Guidance from Virginia’s Real Estate Board and Fair Housing Board says you may ask about the basic nature of the writer’s relationship with the tenant and ask the writer to confirm they follow Virginia’s licensing rules, including telemedicine guidance where it applies. That guidance dates from 2017 and isn’t binding; the statute controls.
- Answer promptly, in writing. The same guidance warns that undue delay could be treated as a denial, and says a temporary exception while you wait may be prudent.
- Keep the paperwork confidential.
Online certificates: the Virginia Fair Housing Office warns that sites selling registrations may suggest a purchase qualifies an animal for pet-free housing. The right rests on a disability, not on a registered animal. A certificate is one thing to weigh, not an automatic yes or no.
If you think a letter is fraudulent: a listed provider who gives fraudulent documentation commits a prohibited practice under the Virginia Consumer Protection Act (subsection F). Talk to your attorney before you act.
What you can’t do
- Charge a pet fee, pet deposit or extra rent for the animal (§ 36-96.3:1, subsection A). Ask your attorney how an ordinary security deposit fits in.
- Demand a diagnosis or medical records. The Board guidance says not to ask about the specific nature of the impairment.
- Require training or certification.
- Accept only a doctor’s note.
- Deny based only on breed, size or type, or point to the no-pets clause.
- Let the request sit unanswered.
- Coerce, intimidate, threaten or interfere with a tenant using these rights (Va. Code § 36-96.5).
What you can do
- Require the tenant to follow the lease and rules that apply to everyone, as long as they don’t block equal use of the home.
- Hold the tenant responsible for physical damage if tenants with pets would be under the lease or state law.
- Deny on the specific grounds in § 36-96.3:2.
- Raise undue burden. The factors include cost (including a substantial insurance increase), your financial resources, the benefit to the tenant and alternatives. If you raise it, you must offer a good-faith conversation about an alternative that works.
FAQ
Can I charge a pet fee or pet rent for an ESA?
No. The tenant can’t be required to pay a pet fee, pet deposit or additional rent for an assistance animal, but is responsible for physical damage if tenants with pets would be.
Can I ask for an ESA letter?
Sometimes. If the disability or the need isn’t obvious or known, you can ask for reliable documentation of both. If they are, you can’t ask for more.
Is an online ESA certificate enough?
Not by itself. What matters is a disability and a disability-related need, backed by reliable documentation.
Did HUD’s 2025–2026 changes let Virginia landlords refuse ESAs?
No. HUD withdrew its old guidance and narrowed its own enforcement, but that doesn’t change Virginia’s statute. Ask an attorney before relying on it.
Again, this is general information, not legal advice. For questions about the law, a Virginia attorney or the Virginia Fair Housing Office (804-367-8530) can help.
If you’re tired of being a landlord
Requests like this, on top of repairs and tenant calls, can make a rental feel like a second job. If you’d rather keep renting, a clear written process helps, and so does careful tenant screening next time.
Selling doesn’t erase a pending request or your fair housing duties while the tenant lives there, and an ESA request is never a reason to end a tenancy. But if you’re ready to stop being a landlord for your own reasons, we buy Richmond-area rentals with the tenant still living there. Our post on selling your house with tenants covers the basics.
Call (804) 293-0208 and tell us about the house and the lease, or use our cash offer form. We return calls within 3 hours and get you a no-obligation offer within 24 hours. We pay the closing costs and close through a local real estate attorney. Here’s how we buy houses.